Gender-Neutral Child Speaks About ‘Silly’ Gender-Roles
You may recall the somewhat disturbing case of the ‘gender-neutral’ child born five years ago – his/her parents did not want him to be stereotyped as either gender and refused to divulge his/her gender to anyone other than immediate family (and even they had to wait some months before they were told). He/she was given the name Sasha, which is perhaps suitably gender-neutral. When the child was old enough to start school, it was revealed that in fact he is a boy.
Now that he is old enough to pull some sentences together, he has been filmed by his mother and the video posted on the net. The topic? What else – how silly it is to have differences between girls and boys.
Sasha Laxton, five, laughs on the video and dismisses the notion that boys should like blue and girls should like pink, which is perhaps fair enough. His mother, Beck, asks him if he thinks girls and boys are different at all, and he says a firm, ‘No.’
This is perhaps not that surprising though. At five, most boys and girls still play together and it is only really as they enter their first proper year of school that the genders tend to separate themselves, with boys preferring to play with boys and girls with girls. Those who prefer to play with the opposite gender can often be left feeling isolated and rejected as their peers seek to form friendships with members of the same sex.
I have to admit, my son’s favourite colour was always pink. I didn’t like to discourage it and felt that he should enjoy what he wanted to, rather than what he ‘should’ enjoy at such a young age. But one evening he said, “mummy, I do not like pink any more. It is a girl’s colour.” I asked what had made him think that and he said, “because they asked us at school what is our favourite colour and I said pink and everyone laughed.”
I felt immediately guilty that I hadn’t protected my son from that. But I’m still not sure how best to deal with behaviour that doesn’t align with a child’s gender – do you go along the ‘don’t do that, it’s for girls/boys’ route, point out more gender-suitable objects, or just allow them to make their own choices?
Beck Laxton is perhaps, some would argue, taking things a bit far and is perhaps setting her son up for a big shock once he discovers the big wide world. Talking to him on the video clip, she asked, ‘What about dressing up in a tutu and being a fairy? Do you remember when you did that for Christmas and I sent it on the Christmas cards because you looked so beautiful?’
Beck Laxton, who hails from Cambridgeshire, said of her decision to raise Sasha as gender neutral that, ‘I wanted to avoid all that stereotyping. Stereotypes seem fundamentally stupid. Why would you want to slot people into boxes?’
Sasha’s dad, Mr Cooper, said, ‘If Sasha wants to dress up in girls’ clothes then so be it. But we’re not forcing it. The girls’ clothes and fancy dress are for fun at home. We don’t make Sasha go out in girls’ clothes.’
Is this passive-parenting or an experiment too far?